|
Spider-Man
2
Rating:
* * 7/8
The movie has some laugh-out
loud moments, some heartwarming and some tear-jerking moments, some good
character bits, some challenges for us to be the sacrificing hero, and
some cool Spidey poses and stunts, but it has real weaknesses, too.
For one thing, Kirsten Dunst
can not match the excellent level of acting of the other cast members,
most notably the great Tobey Maguire, and Alfred Molina, and J.K. Simmons.
So maybe its good that she doesn't have many scenes with Tobey.
However, that brings up a second
weakness. We more or less have to just accept the movie's assertion
that Mary Jane and Peter are the best of friends who need each other and
its point of view that MJ is incredibly desirable on faith, because what's
on the screen never proves it to us.
Third weakness: While
Peter Parker is the original "Hard Luck Hero" in the comic books, he also
fights back at life with his wise-cracking wit and penchant for practical
jokes. This aspect of Peter's personality is on screen a little,
but it is so underemployed that, for the most part, Peter comes across
as this poor schlub who stands around helplessly taking it while life continually
beats him up.
Fourth weakness: Even
though the special effects are superior to those in the first movie, there
are still moments in the film where it is painfully obvious that what you
are watching is essentially an expensive computer game. And this
served to take me right out of the action. In fact, at one point
as Spidey was swinging around the city, I found myself wondering, "Why
did they bother using live-action to tell this story at all? Why
not just make a big budget animated movie, since that's what most of the
action sequences are anyway?"
Fifth weakness: There
are lots of plot holes. I'll just mention a few. How does Peter
survive all those falls? If Peter wants to will his powers to return,
why not try to shoot a web or climb on the walls in his apartment, instead
of leaping off a high-rise building? Why isn't Doc Ock knocked out
by even just one of Spidey's super-powered punches? How can Mary
Jane, on stage, see so clearly who is and isn't in the audience, and why,
if she is supposed to be such a skillful, hot, up-and-coming actress, does
she let it throw her so much? Why does the final solution to the
Dangerous Science Experiment Gone Awry work?
The sixth weakness maybe has
to do more with me than with this film. I have been reading Spider-Man
comic books, off-and-on, at times religiously, for around 40 years.
And I've read the issues and story arcs that inspired this film and that
it pays homage to. So none of the developments in the movie really
surprised me. In fact, I was able to predict what was going to happen
much of the time and found myself, at points, impatient and asking, "When
will this thing be over?" In short, Spider-Man 2 is
an okay movie that could have been good, or even great, if the weaknesses
had been attended to. |